NY Pizza Suprema
A family-run slice institution since 1964 across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden, beloved for the upside-down slice.
Example
With forty minutes before an Amtrak, you cross from Penn Station, order the upside down square and a plain, and eat at the counter.
Best tours and tickets
Curated from Viator. We may earn a commission if you book, at no extra cost to you.
Statue of Liberty & Ellis Island Tour with Reserved Ferry Entry
★★★★★ 4.8 · 14,887 reviews
From $59View tour
Related terms
NYC slang
Slice Joint
A no-frills pizzeria selling pizza by the slice over the counter, eaten standing up or folded on the go.
Landmarks
Times Square
The neon canyon at Broadway and Seventh Avenue, the world's most visited and most locally avoided intersection.
Restaurants
Keens Steakhouse
An 1885 Midtown chophouse famous for its legendary mutton chop and 45,000 antique churchwarden pipes on the ceilings.
Pizza
Joe's Pizza
The Greenwich Village slice shop operating since 1975, widely cited as the benchmark for the classic New York plain...
Frequently asked questions
What should I order at NY Pizza Suprema?
The upside-down slice and a plain. The two together cost less than most Penn Station meals and beat all of them.
Is it open late after events at the Garden?
It runs until around midnight most nights, which covers most post-game crowds. Expect a rush right after final buzzers.
Is it a good stop before a game at Madison Square Garden?
Yes. It sits directly across from the arena and runs late enough for most post game crowds, with a fast counter line instead of arena concession prices.
